Tower Fan vs. Box Fan According to Reddit (2022)

Tower fans and box fans are two of the best types of fans, but even among these, there are numerous options and features to consider. We will go through the different features and functions of these two types of fans in more detail below.

Box fans move air in a straight path from the back to the front. If you want your box fan to blow air in a specific direction, you must point it in that direction. This feature is excellent if you want to dry a wet area on the carpet or if you like having air blown straight at you.

A tower fan, on the other hand, can blow air in practically any direction. You can pick movement at 180-degree angles with an oscillating tower, or you may be able to move air up and down as well.

With this type of oscillating power, you can move air through a bigger area with a smaller fan, and most tower fans have several speed settings that allow you to blow stronger or softer depending on your preference or needs at the time.

Box fans are, on the whole, uncomplicated. Some versions are pedestal-mounted and have oscillation, although simple box fans blow air in a straight line. That is not to imply they aren’t useful in a variety of scenarios, but they lack in terms of features.

There are many various varieties of tower fans on the market, each with its own set of characteristics such as quiet operation, a remote control, and a timer. Natural breeze settings and ionizers are examples of advanced features.

Both fans are lightweight and portable. You can put them wherever you like for your intended use. They do, however, appear to be significantly distinct. A box fan is a fan enclosed in a cage of plastic lattice or steel grille.

This semi-open cage allows air to circulate, allowing the fan to cool the room. They are usually rectangular, square, or round in shape. You can swiftly move them across rooms and even position them in windows to eliminate odors.

Here is our recommended Box Fan on Amazon


A tower fan is likewise portable, but it takes up less room due to its vertical ‘tower’ shape. It can be placed atop a desk, table, bookshelf, or any other tiny space. These are normally quiet fans, making them ideal for situations when you don’t want a lot of noise.

Tower supporters are also more unassuming. Because they take up less space and are available in a variety of forms, they are elegant enough to mix in with a wide range of different types of decor. The word “tower fan” refers to a variety of choices.

Because they are simpler, box fans are often less expensive. They are also simple to fix and inexpensive to replace. A tower fan contains more complex components that may necessitate a return to the manufacturer for service.

They are also more expensive to replace. Both fans are excellent for their intended purpose, and you can select the one that is best for you.

Here is our recommended Tower Fan on Amazon

Tower fan

Which is better, a Box fan or a Tower fan?

Below we will go through the benefits and drawbacks of the two types of fans (Tower fan and Box fan, pros, and cons).

Advantages of a Box fan

Efficient and effective:

  • Tower fans have a lower CFM than box fans.
  • They are effective at removing smoke, dust, or odors from a room, especially if placed near a window where the air can be pushed out.
  • Some box fans are more powerful than others, but the majority of them will perform the job well.

The purchase price is low

  • Box fans are significantly less expensive than most tower fans.
  • If money is a key aspect in your decision, box fans are far less expensive than tower fans.
  • However, keep in mind that you get what you pay for, so anticipate them to be less versatile and dynamic than tower fans.

Small and portable

  • Because of their design, box fans are relatively compact.
  • They are often rectangular in shape, but they can also be circular.
  • They are small and easy to transport, allowing you to carry them and install them wherever you need them.
  • When carrying the device, the plastic grill protects you from the blades.

Running costs are low

  • Box fans can be operated for as little as 2 cents per hour, in certain situations; this makes box fans incredibly cost-effective.

Cool air can be drawn in through windows

  • According to home guides, using a box fan in a window can assist pull in cool air from outside or, if reversed, can draw heated air out of the room.
  • You can chill your house at night by installing box fans in the windows. This means saving money on air conditioning during the day and taking advantage of reduced power prices at night.

Box Fan Filter

  • If you are handy with tools, you can convert your box fan into a box fan filter.

Simple upkeep

  • Box fans may be replaced without spending a lot of money because they are quite inexpensive.
  • They are also less difficult to maintain and do not necessitate the assistance of a specialist in the event of a malfunction.
  • Each fan comes with an instruction manual that should be sufficient to teach you how to care for it.

The disadvantages of a Box fan

It is not physically appealing

  • Box fans are unsuited for interiors where design and aesthetics are crucial.
  • When placed in well-designed houses and offices, they stick out and are an eyesore.
  • If the appearance of your area is important to you, a box fan may not be the best option.

Limitation of features

  • Box fans lack oscillation and varied wind modes, not to mention other fancy features like ionizers and timers.
  • What you get with a box fan is straightforward: strong airflow in the direction you spin the fan.
  • If you require a fan with more features, you should not settle for a box fan.

Noise

  • Box fans are, indeed, extremely loud.
  • Some models will clearly be noisier than others, always read the reviews since the feedback will often say whether or not the noise is an issue for buyers.
  • If you want a fan that will run while you sleep, a boxed fan may not be the best choice because it is highly loud and lacks remote control and mode options.

There is no airflow control feature

  • When it comes to directing the air coming from a box fan, you don’t always have many alternatives.
  • Frequently, the only alternative is to let the air blow in a straight path in front of the fan.
  • If you wish to modify the direction of the airflow, you must move the fan and position it accordingly.
  • Many box fans lack a rotation option, which is a problem unless you intend to use the fan in a single location, blowing just in one direction.

The advantages of a Tower fan

Aesthetic appeal

  • Because they have a more modern style than box fans, these fans can be used in a variety of settings.
  • They will not detract from the décor of your space if you place them in a corner or near the sofa.

Safety

  • Tower fans are relatively safe to use in home settings, despite having so many features in one device.
  • The blades are properly protected, and they have a very stable base, so they will not be easily knocked down.

Purification of the air

  • Some tower fan models include an air purification feature, which produces a healthier environment overall.
  • This is quite beneficial to people who suffer from asthma or allergies, and it is especially beneficial if you have children in the house.

Additional features

  • The best part about tower fans is that they have a ton of fascinating functions that you can experiment with.
  • These include a nightlight, an ionizer, several speed settings, and modes such as breeze mode and sleep mode.
  • Most tower fans also include a timer that allows you to specify how long the fan will run.
  • This is especially useful if you intend to leave the fan running while sleeping.

Suitable for a variety of room sizes and venues

  • Tower fans, due to their design, can fit into corners and limited locations.
  • These fans’ settings allow you to tailor them to the size of the room in which they operate.
  • If you’re in a larger area, you’ll need more airflow, so simply turn up the power, however in a smaller room, you may tone it down and tune it to your liking.
  • Tower fans have a narrow base, allowing them to fit into and be stored in tiny areas.

Various pricing options

  • When it comes to tower fans, you have a variety of price points to choose from.
  • Despite being more expensive than box fans, you may still choose between higher and lower-priced devices.
  • Having this flexibility in pricing is beneficial to your budget, but keep in mind that you get what you pay for.
  • Even the cheapest options include a lot of features, but they are likely of worse quality than the more expensive ones.

The disadvantages of Tower fans

Longevity

  • The lifespan of a tower fan is mostly determined by the price you pay for it.
  • Some versions are more durable than others, but they also cost more.
  • If you want a fan that will last for a long time, don’t go with the less expensive tower fan selections.
  • Furthermore, if you invest in quality once, you will never have to pay for new fans again.

Difficult to maintain

  • Unlike box fans, if a tower fan fails, you will need a professional electrician to inspect the equipment or you will need to take the device to a specialist service to get it repaired.
  • In any case, unless you have prior familiarity with electrics and tower fan units, do not attempt to repair it yourself.
  • Box fans win the battle when it comes to upkeep.

It is not an air conditioner

  • Even though tower fans have many useful characteristics, such as an air purifying ionizer, they are not a replacement for an air conditioning unit.
  • If you want to effectively cool the AC, the only equipment that can give such power is an actual AC device.
  • As a result, while these fans do a superb job of freshening air, they cannot replace air conditioners.

Conclusion

The difference between a tower fan and a box fan is that a box fan is portable, inexpensive, low-maintenance, and diverse in its application (with a little DIY), whereas a tower fan can be controlled remotely, rotates according to the setting (oscillates), and has more control options.

Tower fans are more adaptable in terms of usage because you can modify the settings, adjust the speed, utilize multiple modes, and control the airflow by turning the device.

If you’re concerned about aesthetics and how a fan will look in your home, tower fans provide you with a lot more possibilities.

Consider which fan types are best suited to your needs in terms of room size, type of use, and style.

If you’re on a tight budget, box fans are unquestionably less expensive, but remember that investing once in higher-quality tower fans means saving money on future fan purchases for a long time.

Here is our recommended Box Fan from Amazon


If you want a combination of a tower fan and a box fan, you could consider a pedestal fan and see how it compares to a tower fan.

Here is our recommended Box Fan from Amazon

Tower fan

Which is the major difference between a box fan and a tower fan?

Box fans are far less expensive and may be utilized in a variety of ways with a little tinkering, are more portable, and are also easier to maintain.

Tower fans have more features and convenience with remote controls, circulate more air than box fans, and have more aesthetically pleasing options.

What is the distinction between a pedestal fan and a tower fan?

While a pedestal fan stands tall and proud, blowing air from a height, tower fans typically blast air up their whole height. This is the primary distinction between the two.

They aren’t the most attractive or modern fans, but they can be used behind a couch or other piece of furniture.

Read:- How Much Energy Does a Tower Fan Use?